Read the Blog · News & Events

Whose Reputation Does a Leader Carry?

By James H. Killian, Ph.D. ·

Imagine a sales director ending a call with a customer by promising, “We’ll have you up and running by the first of the month.” Afterward, an account manager stays behind. “We can’t deliver by the first,” she says. “I checked with the team this morning.” This is "The Go-Live Gap."

The Go-Live Gap makes me interested in what the director does in the next five minutes. He could ask her to see what the team can pull off. He could also pick up the phone. “I gave you a date before I’d checked with the people doing the work. That was my mistake. How much flexibility do you have, and what would a delay mean on your end?”

The customer still has a problem. But now she has time to do something about it. The account manager has learned something, too. The next time she spots a problem, she knows her boss will hear her out. One uncomfortable phone call has shaped both the employee experience and the customer experience.

That’s what I mean by character in leadership. We give talented people authority because we trust what they can do. Once they have it, other people have to live with how they use it.

Consider Astronomer. In 2025, CEO Andy Byron resigned after a concert camera showed him embracing Kristin Cabot, the company’s CHIEF PEOPLE OFFICER. What stayed with me about that story was her role. Imagine being an employee who needed to raise a sensitive concern about the CEO the following Monday. Whom would you feel comfortable calling? An employee could reasonably ask that question without knowing anything more about the relationship.

Just yesterday, Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang acknowledged being unfaithful to his wife. The New York Times identified the woman as Alice Huang, a former executive at Megaspeed, an Nvidia customer, and reported that U.S. authorities had concluded she gathered intelligence for Beijing. What Jensen Huang knew about her alleged role remains unclear.

Lord Acton wrote, “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” The word I keep coming back to is tends. Think about how easily an exception becomes a habit. A senior leader asks someone to skip a review so a deal can close this quarter. The person being asked knows they would turn down the same request from a colleague. They also know who signs off on their next promotion. The next time a deal is close, they may skip the review before anyone asks.

Warren Buffett’s observation that a reputation can take twenty years to build and five minutes to ruin raises a question I wish we asked more often. Whose twenty years? Think of the account manager who has spent a decade giving a customer advice they can rely on. When her director makes a promise on behalf of the company, some of what makes him believable is the fact that she has kept her word.

I’d love to hear from the XM community on this. What did a leader do, in an ordinary moment, that made you proud to say, “I work with them”?