Read the Blog · News & Events

When Customers Share the Pain, Who Gets the Upside?

By James H. Killian, Ph.D. ·

When costs go up, customers feel it. If the price of an electric drill goes up, the company explains that tariffs made it more expensive to import. Fair enough. Now suppose some of those costs come back to the company as a refund. Does anyone in the room ask what should come back to the customer? If tariffs disappear, do the companies cut their prices back to what they were tariff? Unlikely.

Stanley Black & Decker and Walmart recently faced versions of that decision. Where they put the money tells us something about how customer-driven leadership shows up when there’s a real choice to make.

Two decisions about where the money goes…

Stanley Black & Decker raised prices and cited tariffs as a reason, according to ProPublica, which reported that the company was getting at least $298 million back. On its November earnings call, the company said higher incentive compensation, growth investments and taxes absorbed part of the refund benefit. That raises a fair question for the leaders who approved those decisions. How much weight did they give to the customers who had already paid higher prices?

Walmart disclosed that it received about $2.9 billion and put a significant portion toward pricing and other efforts to cushion customers from rising costs. On its November earnings call, Walmart linked the refunds to those investments and reported about 7,700 active U.S. price rollbacks. Management also said the rollbacks helped Walmart gain market share in food. For shoppers, the benefit showed up in the price of a grocery trip. For Walmart, it gave shoppers a reason to come back - Walmart created reasons for customers to continue being customers.

This is what I call the "customer-driven" choice.

In Obsessed, I draw a distinction between customer-centric and customer-driven leadership. A customer-centric leader pays attention to what customers need. A customer-driven leader lets what customers need change a decision about how the company spends its money.

A retailer can change a shelf price. A manufacturer that sells through retail partners may need those partners to help shoppers see the savings. And bonuses can make sense when they reward teams for what they did to navigate a difficult year. I’d still want a compensation committee to ask how much of the improvement came from the team’s work and how much came from a refund. Those are different reasons for earnings to go up.

Here’s the test I’d use in the next leadership meeting. Before you decide where an unexpected gain goes, ask who helped absorb the original cost and what they could see from your decision. For a retailer, that might be a lower grocery bill. For a manufacturer, it might be working with retail partners to bring down the price of a product customers buy every day.

If your customers helped carry the cost on the way up, where do they show up in the decision when the money comes back?